Hills like White Elephants


 At a train station in Barcelona a couple are having a very important conversation that will change their lives forever.  The couple, an American man and his girl are having drinks at the train station waiting to go to Madrid Spain and get into a debate on whether to keep the baby or to have an operation consisting of air to remove the baby.  Jag, the female seems to be trouble by the discussion, she wants to make the man happy but towards the end of the conversation seems to want to keep the baby also.  She is conflicted on what to do trying to convince him that things could still be the same if they had the baby.  Where the man flat out tells her, he doesn’t want it by telling her “I don’t care anything about it”.  The man expresses that he loves this woman and shows signs of being selfish in wanting to keep the girl all to himself without interference from a child.  The girl seems to want to make the man happy and give him what he wants but wants to be happy herself. 

Comments

  1. Esin OzildizSeptember 19, 2019 at 12:24 PM

    I believe the girl is hesitant about aborting the child. The child becoming the doom of their relationship. Everything about the story depicts the number”two” which leaves me to believe that three would be a burden and two being a perfect number. Just the two of them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SinahyaOctober 7, 2019 at 2:10 PM

      This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. SinahyaOctober 7, 2019 at 2:13 PM

      This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. SinahyaOctober 7, 2019 at 2:16 PM

      Esin, my perspective is actually similar to yours. It seems to me that the woman is in fear that their whole lives will change if she goes through with having the baby. Whereas the man is portraying to be nonchalant and is leaving the burden of the decision on the woman with no real opinion but reading in between the lines it appears that he is not interested in her actually having the baby without him actually saying it.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Good Man is Hard to Find

After reading the story A Good Man is Hard to Find I have mixed emotions on whether the family had it coming to them for being killed or if I should feel sorry for them. The whole family seems to disrespect the grandmother and she in returns seems to manipulate them. When they run into “The Misfit” an escaped murder she tries to convince him that he is a good man as his friends are killing her family. She tires to save her self-saying you wouldn’t shoot a lady and doesn’t try to safe her family.   What grandmother wouldn’t try to save her son or grandchildren?   At the end when the misfit himself shoots the grandmother three times made me believe he didn’t believe he could ever be a good man like she was implying,   he saw right through her manipulative ways just trying to save herself.
Read more

A & P

The story A & P is about a young man who works at the local supermarket as a cashier. When three girls walk in wear nothing but bikinis the young man seems to watch there every move. Not only is noticing every each of them but her also is paying attention to what he believes is there character just by how they are carrying themselves.  This is where he talks about the leader whom he calls Queenie. When the girls come to his register to check out the store manager comes over and makes a scene about how the girls are dressed asking them to cover up the next time they come in the store. The leader blushes from being embarrassed by the manger and pays for her creamed herring and leaves the store. The young man trying to defend the girls tells the manager he was wrong for saying something to the girls and quits his job leaving the store to find the girls. Feeling as though he was there hero for defending them against the manager only to find himself in the parking lot all alone for ...
Read more